Scams · 6 min read
Is this listing a scam? How to check any online listing in 2 minutes
By Second Look ·
The short answer
To check if a listing is a scam, run four quick tests: the price test (is it far below what the item usually sells for?), the seller test (a new profile, a story about being away, no way to meet), the payment test (bank transfer, gift cards, crypto, “friends and family” payments or a payment link sent in chat) and the pressure test (urgency, a deposit to reserve). One red flag means ask more questions; two or more, especially a low price with an unusual payment method, means walk away.
Scam listings look like real ones. They use real photos, sensible descriptions and believable stories. What gives them away is almost always the same small set of patterns, and you can check for them in a couple of minutes, on any site: marketplaces, classifieds, car sites, rental listings or social media.
1. The price test
Search for the same item and compare a few similar listings. A price far below what it usually sells for is the single most common sign of a scam: it is there to make you act fast and stop asking questions. A sensible discount is normal; a sealed new phone at a third of its price is not. Our guide to working out a fair second-hand price shows how to compare quickly.
2. The seller test
- A brand-new profile, or one with no history, ratings or other listings.
- A story about being away: deployed, working offshore, moved abroad, looking after a relative.
- No way to meet or view the item, especially for expensive or local items such as cars and furniture.
- Moving the chat elsewhere, to WhatsApp, email or text, away from the site where the listing is.
- Photos that look like stock or catalogue images, or a seller who says the photos are “from the internet, but mine looks the same”. A reverse image search often finds them elsewhere.
3. The payment test
This is the most important test, because it is where the money goes. Be very wary of a seller who asks for:
- Bank transfer to a stranger before you have the item.
- Gift cards or crypto, which no real seller needs.
- “Friends and family” payments on PayPal or similar, which remove buyer protection.
- A payment or “secure delivery” link sent in chat, especially one that asks for your card details. These are often fake pages.
- An escrow or shipping service the seller chooses and you have never heard of.
See how to pay safely when buying second-hand for the methods that do protect you.
4. The pressure test
- “Lots of interest, first to pay gets it.”
- “Send a deposit to reserve it.” A deposit for an item you haven’t seen is a classic scam.
- “Price is only this low today.”
- Refusing to answer simple questions, or getting annoyed when you ask them.
A message that tests the seller
Hi, I’m interested. Could I see it in person before paying, and pay when I collect it? Could you also send one more photo of it next to today’s newspaper or a note with my name? Thanks!
A genuine seller will usually say yes, or explain why not. A scammer will avoid the viewing, push the deposit or stop replying.
Let an extension do the check
Second Look is a Chrome extension that runs these checks on the listing you have open. Click once and it reads the page, then tells you to buy, negotiate or walk away, with the red flags it found, a fair price range, the real cost of owning the item, questions to ask and a message you can send the seller. It reads only the listing text, never the item itself, so the in-person checks still matter. The first 3 checks are free and need no account.
For specific sites and items, see Facebook Marketplace scams and used car scams.
Common questions
- How can I tell if an online listing is fake?
- Check four things: a price far below what the item usually sells for, a seller who can’t meet or has a new profile, a request for an unusual payment method, and pressure to pay or send a deposit quickly. Two or more together usually mean a scam.
- Is there a tool that checks if a listing is a scam?
- Yes. Second Look is a Chrome extension that reads the listing you have open and flags scam signs, checks the price against similar items and tells you whether to buy, negotiate or walk away. The first 3 checks are free.
- What payment methods do scammers ask for?
- Bank transfers before delivery, gift cards, crypto, “friends and family” payments that remove buyer protection, and fake payment or escrow links sent in chat.
- What should I do if I think a listing is a scam?
- Don’t pay or share personal details, report the listing on the site, and if you have already paid, contact your bank or payment provider straight away.