Second Look

Negotiating · 6 min read

How to work out a fair price for anything second-hand

By Second Look ·

The short answer

A fair second-hand price is what the same item, in similar condition, has actually sold for recently, not what sellers are asking. Find five or more sold examples, adjust for condition, age, missing accessories and any repairs needed, and you have a fair range. Offer from the lower half of that range and let the seller’s answers move you up.

Most second-hand prices are guesses. Sellers often price based on what they paid, what they hope to get or the highest listing they saw. Buyers then compare one asking price with another. A fair price comes from somewhere else: what people actually paid. Here is a method that works for phones, laptops, furniture, bikes, cameras and almost anything else.

Step 1: identify exactly what it is

The details change the price more than people expect. Write down the brand, exact model, year, size or storage, colour if it matters, and condition. “iPhone 13, 128 GB” and “iPhone 13 Pro, 256 GB” aren’t comparable, and neither are a 2019 and a 2022 version of the same laptop.

Step 2: find sold prices, not asking prices

Asking prices tell you what sellers want. Sold prices tell you what buyers paid. Some marketplaces let you filter by sold or completed listings, eBay’s “Sold items” filter being the best known. Use that where you can. Where you can’t, look at how long similar items have been listed: anything still unsold after weeks is probably overpriced.

  • Aim for at least five comparable sales from the last few months.
  • Ignore the highest and lowest. Extremes are usually special cases.
  • Note the condition and what was included in each.

Step 3: adjust for this item

  • Condition: visible wear, scratches, dents and stains lower the price.
  • Wear parts: a worn battery, tyres, chain or brake pads all have a known replacement cost. Take it off.
  • Missing parts: chargers, cables, remotes, keys, manuals, boxes.
  • Repairs needed: get a rough repair quote and subtract it, plus something for the hassle.
  • Extras: a case, spare parts, receipt or remaining warranty add value.
  • Transport: collection costs for big items are part of what you pay.

Step 4: think about timing and demand

Prices move with the season and the market. Bikes and garden furniture tend to sell for more in spring, convertibles in summer, and prices for phones and laptops usually drop after a new model comes out. Popular items in short supply sell close to the asking price. Common items with many listings leave more room to negotiate.

Step 5: decide your offer

  1. Your fair range is the middle of the sold prices, adjusted for this item.
  2. If the asking price is inside that range, offer from the lower half and expect to meet in the middle.
  3. If it is above the range, make an offer near the fair price and explain why, politely, with facts.
  4. If it is far below the range, be careful. A price that looks too good is one of the strongest scam warning signs.
Offer message with a reason
Hi! I’m interested in your [item]. Similar ones in this condition have been selling for around [price range], and this one [needs a new battery / is missing the charger]. Would you accept [your offer]? I can collect [day].

Our guide to negotiating a second-hand price has more messages for different situations.

Quick rules of thumb

  • Electronics lose value fastest in their first year or two and when a new model launches.
  • Well-known brands with good reputations hold value better, so a big discount on one deserves a closer look.
  • Solid, well-made furniture holds value. Cheap flat-pack sells for far less than it cost new.
  • Cars have their own method: see is this used car price fair? and the true cost of owning a used car.

Common questions

How do I know if a second-hand price is fair?
Compare it with what at least five similar items in similar condition have actually sold for recently, not with other asking prices. Adjust for condition, missing parts and any repairs needed.
How much should I offer below the asking price?
There is no fixed percentage. Work out the fair range from sold prices, then offer from the lower half of that range. If the asking price is far above the range, offer near the fair price and explain why.
Where can I see what used items actually sold for?
Some marketplaces have a sold or completed listings filter, such as eBay’s “Sold items”. Otherwise, watch how long similar listings stay up: items still unsold after weeks are probably overpriced.
Why is a very cheap listing a warning sign?
Scammers often use prices far below market value to attract buyers quickly and get them to pay before seeing the item. A price that is too good to be true deserves extra checks.