Second Look

Scams · 7 min read

How to pay safely when buying second-hand: what protects you and what doesn’t

By Second Look ·

The short answer

The safest way to pay for a second-hand item is to pay in person after you have inspected it, or to pay through the marketplace’s own checkout or a card or PayPal Goods and Services payment that includes buyer protection. Never pay a stranger in advance by bank transfer, instant payment app, gift card or crypto: those payments are very hard to get back.

Most second-hand scams aren’t clever. They work because the buyer pays in a way that can’t be reversed, before seeing the item. If you choose the right payment method, most scams simply stop working. This guide explains which methods protect you, which ones don’t, and what to do if a seller pushes you towards the wrong one.

The one rule

Don’t send money you can’t get back for something you haven’t seen. Almost every safe way to pay follows from that. Either you see the item before the money moves, or the money moves through something that can return it if the item never arrives or isn’t as described.

When you’re buying in person

  • Inspect first, pay second. Test the item, check that it matches the listing, and only then pay.
  • Cash is fine in person. Count it out once you are happy with the item. Meet in a public, busy place, and for expensive items bring someone with you.
  • A bank transfer or payment app in person is fine too, as long as you send it after the inspection and the seller sees it arrive before you leave.
  • For cars, do the transfer at the handover, once you have the keys, the registration documents and a signed receipt. Our used car questions cover what paperwork to ask for.

When the item is posted to you

Buying remotely is where most money is lost, because you have to pay before you can inspect anything. Use a method that can return your money:

  1. The marketplace’s own checkout. Many marketplaces offer buyer protection only when you pay through their system. Paying the seller directly outside the platform usually removes that protection.
  2. PayPal Goods and Services. It includes buyer protection for eligible purchases. Friends and Family does not, which is exactly why scammers ask for it.
  3. A credit card. In many countries card payments can be disputed through your card issuer if goods never arrive.

Payments to avoid with strangers

  • Bank transfers in advance. Once sent, banks often can’t recover the money.
  • Instant payment apps such as Zelle, Venmo or similar services, paid in advance. They are designed for people you know and trust.
  • Gift cards. No real seller asks to be paid in gift cards.
  • Cryptocurrency. Payments can’t be reversed and are hard to trace.
  • Money transfer services such as Western Union or MoneyGram to a stranger.
  • “Escrow” websites the seller suggests. Fake escrow sites are a well-known scam: they look official, take your money and disappear. If you want escrow, choose the service yourself and check it independently.

Deposits: when are they reasonable?

Sellers sometimes ask for a deposit to “hold” an item. For anything you haven’t seen, the answer should usually be no. A popular trick is a car or phone priced well below the rest, with a story about why the seller can’t meet (they are abroad, deployed, moving), and a request for a deposit before a viewing. Once paid, the seller vanishes. If a deposit is truly needed, for example for a dealer reserving a car, pay a small amount by card and get a written receipt with the dealer’s full details.

Scams aimed at the payment itself

  • Fake payment emails. Emails that look like they come from a marketplace or PayPal, saying money is “on hold” until you do something. Check payments only by logging into the app or website yourself.
  • Links to “receive” or “confirm” payment. You never need to click a link or enter card details to receive money.
  • Verification codes. Never share a code sent to your phone. It can be used to take over your account or approve a payment.
  • Overpayment. A buyer or seller who “accidentally” sends too much and asks for the difference back. The original payment usually turns out to be fake or reversed.

Our guide to Marketplace scams covers the most common tricks in more detail.

If you’ve already paid a scammer

  1. Contact your bank or payment provider immediately. The sooner you report it, the better the chance of stopping or recovering the payment.
  2. Report the listing and the account to the marketplace.
  3. Keep everything: screenshots of the listing, messages and payment confirmations.
  4. Report it to the police or your national fraud reporting service. You may need a reference number for your bank.

Common questions

What is the safest way to pay for something on Marketplace?
In person, pay after you have inspected the item, in cash or by bank transfer at the handover. For posted items, use the marketplace’s own checkout, PayPal Goods and Services or a credit card, because those can return your money if the item doesn’t arrive.
Is PayPal Friends and Family safe for buying second-hand?
No. Friends and Family payments don’t include buyer protection, so if the item never arrives you usually can’t get your money back. Use Goods and Services when paying someone you don’t know.
Should I pay a deposit to hold an item?
Not for an item you haven’t seen, and especially not by bank transfer or payment app. Deposits for unseen items are one of the most common second-hand scams.
Can I get my money back after a bank transfer to a scammer?
Sometimes, if you act fast. Contact your bank straight away, report the fraud, and keep all screenshots. Recovery isn’t guaranteed, which is why paying by transfer in advance is risky.