Second Look

Cars · 8 min read

Used car scams: 9 tricks sellers use and how to spot them

By Second Look · · Updated

The short answer

The most common used car scams are rolled-back mileage, cars with unpaid finance, cloned or stolen cars, hidden accident or flood damage, dealers posing as private sellers, and fake listings that ask for a deposit. Almost all of them are caught by the same three habits: check the car’s history yourself, see the car and its documents in person at the registered address, and never pay before the handover.

A car is usually the most expensive thing people buy second-hand, which makes it a target. The good news is that car scams repeat. Once you know the patterns, the warning signs are easy to spot. Here are the nine you are most likely to meet, and what to do about each.

1. Rolled-back mileage

Winding back the odometer makes a car look younger and more valuable. It is illegal in many countries but still happens, and modern digital odometers can be altered too.

  • Compare the mileage with the service history and any inspection records. Mileage that goes down, or a long gap with no records, is a warning sign.
  • Look at wear: a shiny, worn steering wheel, gear knob or pedal rubbers on a car showing very low mileage don’t add up.
  • Use official records where they exist. In the UK, the free MOT history check shows the mileage at every test.
  • More signs and checks: odometer rollback: how to spot fake mileage.

2. Outstanding finance

If the seller still owes money on the car, in some countries the lender can take it back from you, even though you paid. A history check that includes finance records will show this. Ask the seller directly, and ask to see a settlement letter if they say the loan has just been paid off.

3. Cloned or stolen cars

A cloned car carries the identity (number plate and sometimes VIN) of a legitimate car of the same model, to hide that it is stolen. Check that the VIN on the car matches the VIN on the registration document in every place it appears: usually at the bottom of the windscreen, on the driver’s door pillar and under the bonnet. Check the registration document looks genuine, and that the seller’s name and address are on it.

4. Hidden accident damage and “written off” cars

Cars that were declared a total loss after an accident can be repaired and sold without mentioning it. Look for paint that doesn’t quite match between panels, uneven gaps around doors and the bonnet, overspray on rubber seals, and new bolts on panels that shouldn’t have been removed. A history check will often show whether the car has been recorded as a write-off or salvage. See salvage and branded titles for what each brand means.

5. Flood-damaged cars

After floods, water-damaged cars can be cleaned up and sold far from where they were damaged. Smell for damp or mould, look under the carpets and in the boot for silt or rust, check for condensation in the lights, and test every electrical item. In the US, some flood damage is recorded on the title, which a history check shows.

6. Dealers posing as private sellers

Sometimes called “curbstoning”. Traders pose as private sellers to avoid the legal duties that dealers have, often selling cars with problems. Warning signs: the seller has several cars listed, the name on the registration document isn’t theirs, or they ask “which car are you calling about?”.

7. The deposit scam

A desirable car at a low price, a seller who can’t meet because they are abroad, deployed or moving, and a request for a deposit or full payment before delivery. The car usually doesn’t exist. Never pay for a car you haven’t seen, and treat a price far below similar cars as a warning, not a bargain. Our guide on paying safely explains why.

8. Fake escrow and “platform protection”

A variation on the deposit scam: the seller says the payment will be held safely by a marketplace or an escrow service, and sends you a convincing email or link. These are fake. Real marketplaces don’t ask you to send money by bank transfer to hold a car.

9. Problems hidden at the viewing

  • A warm engine when you arrive. Starting problems and smoke are easiest to hide on a warm engine. Ask the seller not to start the car before you get there, and feel the bonnet.
  • Viewing in the rain or the dark. Both hide paint and body damage.
  • A rushed test drive. Drive for at least 15 to 20 minutes, including faster roads if you can.
  • Warning lights that never come on. All dashboard lights should light up briefly when you turn the key. A light that doesn’t may have been disabled.

The checks that stop most scams

  1. Check the price against similar cars. Our guide to checking if a used car price is fair shows how.
  2. Run a history check on the VIN. See how to check a used car’s history.
  3. View it in daylight, at the registered address, with a cold engine.
  4. Match the VIN on the car with the documents.
  5. Pay only at the handover, with the keys and documents in your hand.

Common questions

How can I tell if a used car’s mileage has been rolled back?
Compare the mileage with the service records and any official inspection history, look for gaps or readings that go down, and check whether the wear on the steering wheel, gear knob and pedals matches the mileage shown.
What is the most common used car scam online?
Fake listings for cars priced well below market value, where the seller can’t meet and asks for a deposit or full payment before delivery. The car usually doesn’t exist.
How do I check if a used car is stolen?
Run a history check on the VIN, check the VIN on the car matches the registration document, and view the car at the address on that document. Be wary of sellers who only want to meet in public places.
Is it safe to pay a deposit on a used car?
Only to an established dealer, by card, with a written receipt. Don’t pay a deposit to a private seller for a car you haven’t seen.