Second Look

Cars · 7 min read

Is this used car price fair? How to check in 15 minutes

By Second Look ·

The short answer

A used car price is fair when it sits inside the range of at least five comparable cars: same model, same engine and gearbox, within two years and about 30,000 km of each other. Find that range, adjust for condition and history, and you know whether to pay the asking price, make a lower offer or look elsewhere.

The asking price on a used car is the seller’s opening position, not a fact. Some sellers price high and expect to come down. Some copy the highest listing they can find. A few price low because something is wrong. You can’t tell which from one listing, but you can tell in about fifteen minutes with the method below.

Step 1: write down exactly what the car is

Two cars with the same name can differ in price by thousands. Before comparing anything, note these from the listing:

  • Make, model and year of first registration
  • Engine and fuel (for example 1.5 petrol, 2.0 diesel, hybrid)
  • Gearbox: manual or automatic
  • Trim level, which is the equipment package
  • Mileage
  • Number of previous owners, if stated

If the listing leaves out the engine, the mileage or the year, that is already useful information. A seller who hides basic facts is either careless or hoping you won’t ask. Our list of questions to ask before buying a used car covers what to request.

Step 2: find at least five comparable cars

Go to the biggest car listing site in your country and search with filters that match the car: same model, same fuel and gearbox, registration year within one or two years, mileage within roughly 30,000 km. You want at least five results. If you get fewer, widen the year or the search area a little, but keep the engine and gearbox the same.

Write down the prices. Remove any that are clearly odd: a car with accident damage, an import with missing history, or a dealer listing with a long warranty included. What is left is your comparison group.

Step 3: work out the range

Sort the prices from low to high. Ignore the cheapest and the most expensive, and look at the ones in between. That middle band is the fair range for this kind of car right now.

Remember that these are asking prices. Cars usually sell for somewhat less than they are listed for, so the real sale range is a little lower than what you see.

Step 4: adjust for this car

Now move the car up or down inside the range based on what you know about it.

Reasons it could be worth more

  • A complete service history with receipts
  • One owner from new
  • Mileage clearly below the others
  • Major work done recently: timing belt, clutch, brakes, new tyres
  • A recent inspection passed with no remarks

Reasons it should be cheaper

  • Missing or incomplete service history
  • Mileage clearly above the others
  • An expensive service due soon, such as a timing belt
  • Worn tyres, a cracked windscreen, warning lights
  • Accident repair, or panels that don’t match in colour
  • An inspection that is about to expire

Put a rough cost on each problem. Four new tyres, a timing belt change or a windscreen each have a price you can look up in a few minutes. Those costs are your reasons when you make an offer, and reasons work much better than simply asking for a discount.

Step 5: check the history before you trust the price

A price only means something if the car is what the listing says it is. Before you pay, check:

  • The registration and VIN against your country’s vehicle registry or a paid history report. Look for outstanding finance, a recorded write-off or a stolen marker.
  • The mileage history in inspection records. A reading that goes down between two inspections means the odometer has been changed.
  • The seller’s name against the registration document. If they aren’t the registered owner, ask why.

Step 6: decide

  • Inside the range, with good history: a fair price. You can still ask for a small reduction, but don’t lose a good car over a small amount.
  • Above the range: make an offer near the middle of the range and explain it with your comparable cars and any costs you found.
  • Far below the range: be careful. Either there is a problem you haven’t found yet, or the listing isn’t real. See the signs of a marketplace scam.

When you are ready to make the offer, our guide on how to negotiate a second-hand price has messages you can copy.

Don’t forget the cost after you buy

A cheap car can be an expensive car to own. Before you compare two cars on price alone, look up insurance, yearly tax, fuel use and the cost of the next big service for each. A car that costs 1,000 less to buy but 600 more a year to run is the more expensive choice after two years.

Common questions

How much below the asking price should I offer on a used car?
There is no fixed percentage. Base the offer on comparable cars and on the costs you found, such as tyres or a service that is due. An offer with reasons, near the middle of the fair range, is taken more seriously than a round number.
Is a very cheap used car always a scam?
No, but it needs an explanation. High mileage, missing history, accident damage or an expensive repair can all lower a price honestly. If the seller gives no reason and wants payment before you see the car, treat it as a scam.
Are dealer prices higher than private prices?
Usually, yes. A dealer price normally includes preparation, some form of warranty and legal consumer rights. Compare dealer cars with dealer cars and private cars with private cars.
Does high mileage always mean a lower price?
Mostly, but condition and service history matter as much. A car with higher mileage and a full service record can be a better buy than a lower-mileage car with no history.