Cars · 7 min read
The true cost of owning a used car: how to work it out before you buy
By Second Look ·
The short answer
The true cost of owning a used car is the purchase price plus everything you pay to keep it on the road, minus what you can sell it for later. Add up depreciation, insurance, fuel or charging, tax, servicing, tyres and a repair budget for the years you plan to keep it. A cheaper car with high running costs can cost more over three years than a dearer one.
Two used cars at the same price can cost very different amounts to own. One might need expensive tyres, drink fuel and cost twice as much to insure. Working out the real cost before you buy takes about twenty minutes and stops the asking price from being the only number you compare.
The seven costs to add up
- Depreciation: what the car loses in value while you own it. Often the biggest cost on newer cars, and smaller on older ones that have already lost most of their value.
- Insurance: varies hugely by model, engine size, your age, your address and your driving record. Get real quotes for the exact car before you buy.
- Fuel or charging: your yearly distance divided by 100, multiplied by the car’s real-world consumption and your local price.
- Tax and fees: annual vehicle tax, registration and any inspection fees in your country.
- Servicing: the manufacturer’s schedule, including major items like timing belts, brake fluid and gearbox oil.
- Tyres and brakes: both wear out, and larger or performance tyres cost more.
- Repairs: a yearly budget for things that break. Higher for older, high-mileage or complex cars.
How to estimate each one
Depreciation
Look at what the same model sells for when it is a few years older with more miles. The difference between today’s price and that future price, divided by the years you plan to keep it, is your yearly depreciation. Our guide on checking whether a used car price is fair explains how to find comparable cars.
Fuel
Use real-world consumption from owners rather than the official figure, which is usually optimistic. For example, if you drive 15,000 km a year in a car that uses 6.5 litres per 100 km, that is 975 litres a year. Multiply by your local fuel price. For electric cars, do the same with kWh per 100 km and your electricity price, including any public charging.
Servicing and big jobs
Check the service book against the manufacturer’s schedule. If a major service or a timing belt replacement is due soon, that cost belongs in the first year. Ask a local garage for a quote: it is a phone call that can be worth hundreds.
Repairs
Search for the model and engine with words like “common problems” or “reliability”. Owner forums are good at listing known faults and what they cost. If a known expensive fault hasn’t been fixed yet on the car you are looking at, budget for it.
A worked example
Here are two made-up cars with the same €9,000 asking price, kept for three years and driven 15,000 km a year. The numbers are illustrative, to show the method.
- Car A: a small petrol hatchback. Loses about €3,000 in three years, €450 a year insurance, 5.5 l/100 km, €400 a year servicing, €300 a year repair budget.
- Car B: a larger, older diesel SUV. Loses about €2,500 in three years, €750 a year insurance, 7.5 l/100 km, €700 a year servicing, a timing belt due next year, €700 a year repair budget.
Even though Car B loses less value, its insurance, fuel, servicing and repairs add up to well over a thousand euros a year more than Car A. Over three years the “same price” cars are thousands apart. That is the number to compare, not the asking price.
Quick ways to keep the cost down
- Get insurance quotes for two or three models before you choose, not after.
- Choose common models. Parts are cheaper and more garages know them.
- Avoid cars with a major service due unless the price reflects it.
- Check tyre tread and brand at the viewing. Four new tyres can be a significant cost.
- For short, mostly city trips, a modern diesel can be a poor fit. Diesel particulate filters need longer drives to stay clean.
Common questions
- How much does it cost to own a used car per year?
- It depends on the car, your insurance and how far you drive. Add up depreciation, insurance, fuel or charging, tax, servicing, tyres and a repair budget. For many people the total is several thousand euros or dollars a year, even for a cheap car.
- What is the biggest cost of owning a car?
- For newer cars it is usually depreciation. For older, cheaper cars it is often fuel, insurance and repairs, because there is less value left to lose.
- Is an older car cheaper to own?
- Not always. Older cars lose less value, but repairs and fuel can cost more. Compare the total yearly cost of the specific cars you are considering rather than assuming.