Negotiating · 7 min read
How to negotiate a second-hand price (with messages you can copy)
By Second Look ·
The short answer
To negotiate a second-hand price, find what similar items sell for, make one specific offer with a reason, and make it easy for the seller to say yes: offer to collect soon and pay straight away. A polite offer with a reason gets far better results than “what’s your lowest price?”.
Most people dislike haggling, so they either pay the asking price or send “lowest price?” and get ignored. Neither is needed. Private sellers usually expect an offer and have a lower figure in mind. Your job is to find a number that is fair to both of you and to ask for it in a way that makes the seller want to deal with you.
Before you message: know the fair price
You can’t negotiate well without knowing what the item is worth. Search for the same item in the same condition and note five asking prices. The middle of those is your reference point. For cars, follow our 15-minute method for checking whether a used car price is fair.
Then look for honest reasons the price should be lower: a missing charger, worn tyres, a scratch in the photos, a service that is due, or simply that other listings are cheaper. Each one is a reason you can mention.
Six rules that work
1. Be a person first
Say hello and show you have read the listing. Sellers get dozens of one-word messages. A polite, specific one stands out, and sellers often choose the pleasant buyer over a slightly higher offer from a rude one.
2. Never ask “what’s your lowest price?”
It asks the seller to negotiate against themselves, and most won’t answer. Name a number instead.
3. Make one specific offer, with a reason
“Would you take 420? Similar ones are listed at 400 to 450, and this one needs a new battery” is hard to be offended by. A number without a reason feels like a guess. A reason shows you have done the work.
4. Start a little below your target, not far below
Leave room to meet in the middle, but stay inside what similar items sell for. An offer of half the asking price ends most conversations. If the listing is already fairly priced, a small reduction or no reduction at all is the right result.
5. Make it easy to say yes
Sellers want the item gone without hassle. “I can collect tonight and pay on the spot” is worth real money to them. Speed and certainty are your strongest tools, and they cost you nothing.
6. Be ready to walk away, politely
Decide your maximum before you start. If the seller won’t reach it, thank them and leave your offer open. Sellers often come back a few days later when other buyers haven’t turned up.
Five messages you can copy
Hi! I’m interested in your [item]. I’ve looked at similar ones and they’re listed at around [range]. Would you accept [offer]? I can collect [today / this week] and pay straight away.
Hi, thanks for the clear photos. I noticed [the scratch on the screen / the tyres are worn / there’s no charger], which would cost me about [amount] to sort out. With that in mind, would [offer] work for you?
Thanks for coming back to me. [Their price] is a bit more than I planned. Could we meet in the middle at [price]? I can pick it up [day] and pay on the spot.
It’s mostly as described, thank you. I did notice [issue], which wasn’t in the listing. I’m still happy to take it today for [price]. Does that work?
I understand, and thanks for your time. My offer of [price] stands if you change your mind. Good luck with the sale!
Mistakes that cost you the deal
- Offering far too little. It ends the conversation before it starts.
- Criticising the item. Point out facts, not opinions. “The tyres need replacing” works. “This is overpriced junk” doesn’t.
- Agreeing a price and then asking for less at the door with no new reason. If you find a real problem, say so. Otherwise keep your word.
- Negotiating before you know you want it. Ask your questions first. For cars, use our 25 questions to ask a used car seller.
- Paying a deposit to “lock in” a price. That is how many marketplace scams work. Agree the price, then pay when you collect.
When not to negotiate
If the price is already at the low end of the fair range and the item is in good condition, pay it. Trying to save a small amount on a good deal often means losing it to the next buyer. Negotiating is for getting a fair price, and a fair price is sometimes the one already on the listing.
Common questions
- How much lower can I offer on a second-hand item?
- It depends on how the asking price compares with similar listings. If it is in line with them, expect a small reduction at most. If it is above them, an offer near the middle of the usual range, with your reasons, is fair.
- Is it rude to make a lower offer?
- No. Most private sellers expect one. What sellers find rude is a very low offer with no reason, or a message that only says “lowest price?”.
- Should I negotiate by message or in person?
- Agree a rough price by message so nobody wastes a trip, and adjust in person only if the item is different from the listing.
- What if the seller says the price is firm?
- Respect it. Decide whether the item is worth that price to you. If it isn’t, thank them and leave your offer open in case they change their mind.